October 15, 2021
A young readers' adaptation of the 2017 title by the same name tells the story behind a series of murders in 1920s Oklahoma. Opening with the murder of Anna Brown, a 34-year-old Osage woman, readers are led through the chain of evidence as well as being introduced to critical background information such as the seizure of much Osage territory by the U.S. government and the consequences for Osage people of finding oil on their land. By the time FBI special agent Tom White was put on the case, an Osage man had been murdered and Anna's mother had died under mysterious circumstances, contributing to feelings in the community that they were being targeted for their wealth. The book evokes the atmosphere of the time through photographs and the quoting of sensationalistic newspaper headlines, but the author handles the material respectfully and does not go into graphic detail about the deaths. Each chapter uncovers a new layer of exploitation and corruption in a system that required the Osage to have White guardians who dictated how and where they could spend their money. The bureau's undercover operatives used the latest forensic and investigative techniques to confirm alibis and reveal false identities. The story unfolds in a gripping way, allowing readers to piece together what happened with the information given. This compelling page-turner highlights criminal exploitation of Osage people and the work of the modern FBI. (who's who, glossary, note on sources, sources, notes, illustration credits, index) (Nonfiction. 10-14)
COPYRIGHT(2021) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Starred review from October 10, 2016
New Yorker staff writer Grann (The Lost City of Z) burnishes his reputation as a brilliant storyteller in this gripping true-crime narrative, which revisits a baffling and frightening—and relatively unknown—spree of murders occurring mostly in Oklahoma during the 1920s. From 1921 to 1926, at least two dozen people were murdered by a killer or killers apparently targeting members of the Osage Indian Nation, who at the time were considered “the wealthiest people per capita in the world” thanks to the discovery of oil beneath their lands. The violent campaign of terror is believed to have begun with the 1921 disappearance of two Osage Indians, Charles Whitehorn and Anna Brown, and the discovery of their corpses soon afterwards, followed by many other murders in the next five years. The outcry over the killings led to the involvement in 1925 of an “obscure” branch of the Justice Department, J. Edgar Hoover’s Bureau of Investigation, which eventually charged some surprising figures with the murders. Grann demonstrates how the Osage Murders inquiry helped Hoover to make the case for a “national, more professional, scientifically skilled” police force. Grann’s own dogged detective work reveals another layer to the case that Hoover’s men had never exposed. Agents: Kathy Robbins and David Halpern, Robbins Office.
June 5, 2017
Three voice actors divvy up the task of narrating the audio edition of Grann’s saga of the mysterious murders of at least two dozen members of the wealthy Oklahoman Osage Indian nation. Actor Lee reads the first third of the book, entitled “The Marked Woman,” which largely focuses on the story of Mollie Burkhart Lee, an Osage woman whose family was killed off one by one in the early 1920s. Unfortunately her pacing is so slow that the grammatical structure of sentences is often lost, and she uses the same tone whether the subject is serene scenery or vicious murders. Luckily Patton picks up the pace when reading the middle portion of the book, entitled “The Evidence Man,” which chronicles FBI agent Tom White’s struggles to investigate the case. Campbell ultimately steals the show in the third section, “The Reporter,” which follows the man who uncovered the plot to steal the oil-rich Osage territory. He reads in a voice as gruff as the man the chapter is based on, while clearly communicating the complex plot twist that ends this fascinating chunk of American history. A Doubleday hardcover.
Starred review from November 1, 2021
Grades 6-9 *Starred Review* There is currently a wave of telling history as it truly was--of reinking erasures and repairing narratives to their less glamorous but more honest selves. This young-reader's adaptation of Grann's adult best-seller fits this trend perfectly. The author not only exposes the covert but systematic murders of Osage Native Americans living in Oklahoma during the 1920s, he overturns stereotypical views of Indigenous communities by highlighting the extreme wealth of the Osage due to their oil-rich land and brings to light the outrageous levels of corruption operating at every level of the white-established government and justice system. It is upsetting, to put it mildly, to see how the Osage were oppressed, swindled, and killed with ease and how the "Osage Reign of Terror" has been blotted from history books. Grann gives these historical figures new life, painting a clear picture of victims and villains alike--aided by many archival photos and an appended "Who's Who" list (bookmark it!)--while maintaining the story's intrigue and suspense. Adding to this is his incorporation of the newly formed FBI's role in cracking the case. Grann also includes an eye-opening section about his experience researching the book, adding yet another perspective to this story and how history is documented. An eye-opening, challenging, and thoroughly sourced saga that will open the door to many necessary conversations.
COPYRIGHT(2021) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.